Let's break the last cookie in half

Game theory says one persons breaks it and the other picks which piece they want

Why let theoretical, hypothetical, metaphysical ideals dictate our life

We both know I want the small one

Still, it's a good idea

Let's trade guilty pleasures

Art that we think we shouldn't like

Bands that we know are only nostalgic

Movies which we wouldn't recommend, but want to watch together

Let's keep halving that cookie

Bit by bit promising to each other